Some pupils effectively commented on the fact that those belted could retain elements of shame leading them to become self harmers. Others suggested it could induce a negative atmosphere to learning. One group, led by Karina Mulholland and Darryl Shaw, were keen to point out that belting may even lead to suicide.
Others, including Stephen Williams, Orla Martin, Mikayla Deeley and Jamie Burns, focussed on the case study of a boy who was so scarred from his experience that he suffered serious pain for the rest of his life.
The class concluded that corporal punishment is not an ideal solution to behavioural problems as it never really addresses the deeper issues leading to indiscipline.
Elaine Seehafer
